another one bites the dust…
Oh, Meebo. I really thought you might be the one.
I was excited about Meebo at first because it’s all in the browser, there’s no software to download and install, and I have my browser open all the time anyway, so it seemed like a win-win, one less window to keep open all the time for im. Having said that…I actually don’t like the interface very much. It just felt kind of claustrophobic being stuck in the browser tab. Having to switch from the tab I was reading to mess with the Meebo stuff was irritating. You can pop the ims and buddylist out. but I still ended up having to be in the Meebo tab all the time, and then you’ve got the extra windows open anyway.
I’m probably just a little cranky about it all because it was a bit of a hassle to get stuff going, but that’s only because I have No Script installed and nothing was loading. The blocked scripts weren’t showing up in the windows so I didn’t realize that was the problem right away…you also have to allow the TokBox script for the calls to work. Found it in the right-click menu eventually. Duh, honestly. My bad.
I also installed the Firefox extension for the sidebar. I thought would be great for me because I already have the sidebar open most of the time when I’m browsing (fantastic with the del.ici.ous bookmarks extension). It’s really a shame you have to keep that Meebo tab open, it would be much better to have it all in the sidebar and just pop out the ims when you need to. I wouldn’t mind too much if the tab was just in the background, but you can’t pop out the ims straight from the sidebar. Same with the drag and drop to the sidebar - it would be great and really useful IF it didn’t bring you back to the Meebo tab every single time…grrr.
What else? Welllll, the video calling wasn’t great. The windows are small and they don’t give you a lot of options…none as far as I can tell. Some of the other features were appealing, like being able to share videos and watch in the rooms, but not a significant benefit for me. The voice and video calling being integrated bothers me. A lot. And you can’t be on a voice or video call at the same time as using the other applications like playing games…but the games seemed kinda meh anyway (well the sheep one sucked lol). The pacman and ghosty emoticons, however, were seriously awesome. I wish I could take them with me everywhere I go.
Conclusion: I want a lot more control over my voice and video calling than Meebo offers, but that’s not their thing and that’s cool. I think they have some good features that can only get better, but there’s still plenty of room to improve. Being able to access all your im accounts and use them from any browser could be extremely useful, and it’s reassuring to know that Meebo’s there if I need it. All the same, I don’t really think I’ll get much use out of it.
So there you have it. Sorry Meebo. It’s cool, we can still be friends. :p
